diff --git a/ReallifeGamemode.Server/Commands/FactionCommands.cs b/ReallifeGamemode.Server/Commands/FactionCommands.cs
index 6147647e..5d8c523b 100644
--- a/ReallifeGamemode.Server/Commands/FactionCommands.cs
+++ b/ReallifeGamemode.Server/Commands/FactionCommands.cs
@@ -538,7 +538,11 @@ namespace ReallifeGamemode.Server.Commands
 
         target.TriggerEvent("jailTime", 0);
         targetUser.Wanteds = 0;
-        PositionManager.cuffPoints.Remove(target);
+
+        if (PositionManager.cuffPoints.Contains(player))
+        {
+          PositionManager.cuffPoints.Remove(player);
+        }
 
         targetUser.SetBlipAndNametagColor();